Consistency in long-term observations of oceans and ice from space

Satellite remote sensing has provided powerful tools for constructing long-term records of observations of many of Earth's geophysical processes. Geophysicists studying climage change would like to construct time series of data which are as long, accurate, and consistent as possible. While technological advances continue to improve the quality of observations from space, they also present consistency problems. The scanning multichannel microwave radiometer (SMMR), which operated from October 1978 to August 1987, and the special sensor microwave imager (SSMI), which overlapped with the SMMR for nearly two months in 1987, have provided microwave radiances which have been used to monitor long-term changes in sea ice concentration and snow accumulation, among other things. Inspection has shown, however, that brightness temperatures from the two sensors over the same polar firn-covered scene can differ by as much as 14 K. Calibration corrections for polar firn have been derived; in this paper, we present calculations addressing the physics of the small frequency and viewing angle differences between the SMMR and the SSMI on microwave emission from polar scenes containing free water. We focus here only on surface emission. We use a surface scattering model and study the effects of surface roughness, snow wetness, snow density, and young sea ice concentration. We also compare data from Antarctica with our modeled results. We find that for most scenes, surface roughness dominates over the effects of frequency and viewing angle differences, but that for open long-term times series, data must be calibrated and constructed at the geophysical product level rather than at the level of measured radiances.