Re-examination of a Classic Experiment to Measure the Positronium-Helium Cross Section

In 1975, before the advent of positronium beams, a clever experiment was carried out in an attempt to measure low-energy Ps-atom scattering cross-sections, especially that of Ps-He. A series of parallel thin plates was placed in the vessel containing the sample of gas, and positrons were allowed to enter the chamber from a radioactive source. The time spectrum of annihilation radiation was observed in the traditional way, and the pickoff annihilation due to thermalized Ps striking one of the plates was to be the special feature of the experiment. Using a diffusion analysis the authors derived cross- sections for several gases, and for helium the value obtained was sigma = 0.0166 pi(alpha)(sub o, sup 2). Even then this value was thought to be very much too small, while recent measurements and some calculations suggest a more reasonable value would be sigma = 3 to 13 pi(alpha)(sub o,sup 2). It has always been puzzling that an apparently well-designed experiment should give such an unsatisfactory result. We have now re-examined the analysis of the data with some interesting consequences which may explain the discrepancy. Two main observations support our re-analysis. First, we note that the mean free path for Ps-He scattering would be quite long if the cross-section were as small as that quoted above; the diffusion method itself would seem to be questionable. For the larger values, however, there would be no such problem. Second, it was assumed that when the annihilation rate had settled down and was following an exponential decay curve the asymptotic solution of the diffusion equation had been reached. We find, instead, that a superposition of exponentials can accurately represent the decay curve, consistent with the higher cross-section value.