Biogenic Activity in Selected Martian Meteorites

Criteria are well established within the scientific community for the acceptance of evidence for biogenic activity within samples from the early Earth. The eight criteria are: (1) geologic context, (2) age and stratigraphic location, (3) cellular morphology, (4) colonies, (v) biominerals, (6) isotope patterns, (7) organic biosignatures, and (8) features indigenous to sample. In the case of samples from Mars, we must also apply the same criteria. For the martian meteorite ALH84001, we have presented evidence which indicates possible biogenic activity associated with the 3.94 b.y. old, fracture-bound carbonate deposits. Subsequent major criticism of our hypothesis concerned the fact that many of the biogenic features could have been introduced during the time the meteorite was in Antarctica, prior to its collection. We address the possibility of Antarctic contamination and compare our evidence with accepted criteria for establishing the presence of past life. Although, we are close to matching some of the required criteria (likely biominerals, organic biomarkers, bacterial appendages, microfossils and indigenous features), there are others (well-documented geologic context, and evidence for colonies) which have not yet been met. It is not yet possible to come to a definitive conclusion concerning life on early Mars, but it is hoped that continued research will provide more relevant information.