Investigation of a Diagnostic for Perturbation Theory: Comparison to the T(sub 1) Diagnostic of Coupled-Cluster Theory

A diagnostic for perturbation theory calculations, S(sub 2), is defined and numerical results are compared to the established T(sub 1) diagnostic from coupled-cluster theory. S(sub 2) is the lowest order non-zero contribution to a perturbation expansion of T(sub 1). S(sub 2) is a reasonable estimate of the importance of non-dynamical electron correlation, although not as reliable as T(sub 1). S(sub 2) values less than or equal to 0.012 suggest that low orders of perturbation theory should yield reasonable results; S(sub 2) values between 0.012-0.015 suggest that caution is required in interpreting results from low orders of perturbation theory; S(sub 2) values greater than or equal to 0.015 indicate that low orders of perturbation theory are not reliable for accurate results. Although not required mathematically, S(sub 2) is always less than T(sub 1) for the examples studied here.