The MCH2+ Systems: Do ScCH2+ and TiCH2+ Have C(sub s) or C(sub 2v) Symmetry and A Comparison of the B3LYP Method to Other Approaches

ScCH2(+) and TiCH2(+) are found to have C(sub s) symmetry, while the remaining systems have the expected C(sub 2v) symmetry. The C(sub s) symmetry structure is favored for ScCH2(+) and TiCH2(+) because it allows donation from one of the CH bonds into an empty 3d orbital. This distortion stabilizes the systems by less than 2 kcal/mol at the B3LYP, CASSCF, and CCSD(T) levels of theory. The SCF and B3LYP approaches find the C2(sub v) structure to be a saddle point, while the CASSCF approach finds the C(sub 2v) structure to be a stationary point. For V-Cu there are no empty 3d orbitals of the correct symmetry, and therefore the distortion to C(sub s), is unfavorable. The B3LYP binding energies are in good agreement with experiment and our previous best estimates.