Electron Beam Damage in Apatite: Limitations for SKα Measurements of S6+/∑S

In magmatic systems, the availabil- ity of excess oxygen that can react with multivalent elements such as Fe and S to change their charge (oxi- dation of Fe2+ to Fe3+ or reduction of S6+ to S2-) is characterized by a parameter called the oxygen fugacity (ƒO2). The ƒO2 controls the availability of these ions and consequently the minerals—and the chemistry of those minerals—that crystallize from a melt. Mineral mode and chemistry control how magmas evolve, and given that ƒO2 varies by many orders of magnitude on different planets [2], understanding the ƒO2 of a mag- ma is critical to relating observations about a magma to the body on which it forms. The mineral apatite was long thought to only incor- porate S6+ in a coupled substitution for P5+, but recently natural apatites with S2- were identified in lunar mare basalts that crystallized at low ƒO2 [3]. This suggests that apatite can be used as a monitor of ƒO2 assuming that one can 1) measure S6+/∑S (S6+ over total sulfur), and 2) determine some partitioning relationship be- tween apatite and melt for S6+ and S2-. The most common method for measuring S6+/∑S is X-ray Absorption Near-Edge Spectroscopy (XANES), but given the limited access to synchrotron facilities, it is wise to explore the potential of other methods for measuring S6+/∑S. One such possible method relies upon the shift in energy of the sulfur K-α peak on the electron microprobe. However, apatite is subject to well-documented beam damage [4, 5], so it is neces- sary to evaluate under what conditions can reliable S6+ ethod.