NASA Logo

NTRS

NTRS - NASA Technical Reports Server

Back to Results
Trends in Human Spaceflight: Failure Tolerance, High Reliability and Correlated Failure HistoryIn a half century of human spaceflight, NASA has continuously refined agency safety and reliability requirements in response to mission demands, critical failures, and technology development. Early spacecraft, including Mercury, Gemini and Apollo vehicles, were highly reliant on dissimilar redundancy and demonstrated test margins. Later programs, such as the reusable Space Transportation System (STS) and International Space Station (ISS), introduced probabilistic studies and isolated two-failure tolerance to improve robustness at the expense of added complexity. More recently, the Orion Multi-Program Crew Vehicle (MPCV) program adopted universal single-failure tolerance with two categorical exceptions; Zero-Failure Tolerant (0FT) and Design for Minimum Risk (DFMR) hardware. Failure tolerance variances are defined and managed in accordance with agency human-rating requirements, and require concurrence from program Technical Authorities (TA) as well as the MPCV Safety and Mission Assurance Safety and Engineering Review Panel (MSERP). To understand and reaffirm standards applied to Apollo, Space Shuttle and Orion vehicles, Orion and Deep Space Gateway Safety and Mission Assurance (S&MA) representatives conducted accelerated research to compare unique safety and reliability criteria against ground and flight anomalies, based on information contained in post-mission reports and the Problem Reporting and Corrective Action (PRACA) database. In some cases, high-profile failures and narrow escapes have reinforced decisions to maintain or adapt safety requirements. In others, empirical trends have highlighted the need for vigilance and innovative safety guidelines. Given the inability to achieve absolute compliance with evolving safety and reliability requirements, the team conducted a targeted review of DFMR and 0FT propulsion elements within the framework of changing system design, inspection, materials and process developments to formulate conclusions on technological maturity, failure density, and net changes in safety risk. Based on the aggregate performance of high-reliability and failure-tolerant systems, the authors have attempted to establish best practices and guidelines to inform future program decisions. On a somewhat cautionary note, this study is not intended to direct a universal set of requirements for future missions based on prior lessons learned. Spacecraft safety is a multi-variable problem, and attempts to mitigate past failures will not guarantee future success. However, this assessment offers a retrospective review of policy changes, implementation and effectiveness. In the future, NASA, European Space Agency (ESA) and industry partners may benefit from a more robust correlation between requirements and performance, as space-faring nations work toward more challenging, complex and long-duration commercial and deep-space ventures.
Document ID
20190025830
Acquisition Source
Glenn Research Center
Document Type
Conference Paper
Authors
Green, Carrie
(NASA Glenn Research Center Cleveland, OH, United States)
Havenhill, Maria
(NASA Glenn Research Center Cleveland, OH, United States)
Sadhukhan, Deboshri
(NASA Glenn Research Center Cleveland, OH, United States)
Bobanga, John
(NASA Glenn Research Center Cleveland, OH, United States)
Sadhukhan, Joyoshri
(Ohio State Univ. Columbus, OH, United States)
Fiedler, Matthew
(Ohio State Univ. Columbus, OH, United States)
Date Acquired
June 10, 2019
Publication Date
May 15, 2019
Subject Category
Quality Assurance And Reliability
Report/Patent Number
GRC-E-DAA-TN68045
Meeting Information
Meeting: International Association for the Advancement of Space Safety "Making Safety Happen"
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Country: United States
Start Date: May 15, 2019
End Date: May 17, 2019
Sponsors: Aerospace Corp.
Funding Number(s)
WBS: 747797.03.02.99.03
Distribution Limits
Public
Copyright
Public Use Permitted.
No Preview Available