The Evaluation of Cryogenic Force Balance Calibration Methodologies with Respect to Wind Tunnel Results

Independent tests of the NASA Common Research Model (CRM) at NASA's National Transonic Facility (NTF) and the European Transonic Windtunnel (ETW) revealed discrepancies at low operating temperatures and high Reynolds numbers that warranted further investigation. Since each facility used their own force balance for their tunnel entry, one suggestion for the discrepancy was the temperature compensation methodology developed and applied for each balance. This hypothesis is explored through simulation and experimentally. Independent calibrations of NASA's NTF-118A balance at NASA Langley and ETW reveal discrepancies in the thermal compensation of the normal force and pitching moment primary sensitivities with temperature, while the axial force primary sensitivities are in good agreement. The application of the force balance calibrations performed at NASA and ETW to the prior wind tunnel data suggests that the thermal compensation discrepancies are an order of magnitude less than the discrepancies observed between the wind tunnel aerodynamic coefficients.