Oxidation of the Mantle Wedge by H+ in Aqueous Fluids: A New Interdisciplinary Approach

The observation that arc magmas are the most oxidized on Earth have led petrologists to question whether the subduction process might cause oxidation of the sub-arc mantle source. A strong correlation between the input of slab-derived aqueous fluid and Fe3(+)/ΣFe in arc magmas has led to the hypothesis that slab fluids may facilitiate the transfer of redox potential from oxidized slab material to mantle wedge and subsequently to primary arc melts. Despite this intuitive link, identifying an efficient and ubiquitous chemical process to transfer oxidation state in slab fluids has been challenging. Pure H2O alone is an inefficient oxidizer in the mantle, necessitating another oxidant within the fluid. Commonly invoked components include S or C, which are likely heterogeneously distributed within subducting slabs, and direct transfer of Fe3(+), which is only possible in very solute-rich fluids. Here we present a new mechanism to explain the oxidation of the sub-arc mantle by slab-derived aqueous fluid, wherein dissolved H(+)(aq) is reduced to H2(aq). Redox equilibrium is satisfied by electron transfer from Fe2(+)(s), which is oxidized in the rock to Fe3(+)(s) in the reaction: 2Fe2(+)(s) + 2H(+)(aq) = 2Fe3(+)(s) + H2(aq). This simple reaction was previously overlooked due to the assumption that all H must be bound by H2O molecules (i.e., no dissolved H), applicable to a pure H2O fluid, but not one with a solute load as addressed here. The application of thermodynamic modeling tools from aqueous geochemistry (DEW, EQ3/6) to mantle petrology predicts this reaction between mantle rock and slab fluid with our own experimentally constrained chemistry and fO2 (QFM+2). Mass transfer model results show an increase in Fe3(+)/ΣFe in mantle rock from MORB- like (0.15) to arc-like (0.2–0.3) values at reasonable fluid fluxes, co-incident with increasing H2 activity in the fluid. This can explain the stark correlation between slab fluid input into the mantle wedge and the observed fO2 of arc magmas. Moreover, it does not require diffusion of hydrogen out of the system. Instead, H2 remains dissolved in fluid in equilibrium with oxidized mantle rock.