The relative merits of several numerical techniques for solving the compressible Navier-Stokes equations

Four explicit finite difference techniques designed to solve the time-dependent, compressible Navier Stokes equations are compared. These techniques are: (1) MacCormack, (2) modified Du Fort-Frankel, (3) modified hopscotch, and (4) Brailovskaya. The comparison was made numerically by solving the quasi-one dimensional Navier Stokes equations for the flow in a converging-diverging nozzle. Solutions with and without standing normal shock waves were computed for unit Reynolds numbers (based on total conditions) ranging from 45374 to 2269. The results indicate that all four techniques are comparable in accuracy; however, the modified hopscotch scheme is two to three times faster than the Brailovskaya and MacCormack schemes and three to six times faster than the modified Du Fort-Frankel scheme.