The origin of spurious solutions in computational electromagnetics

The origin of spurious solutions in computational electromagnetics, which violate the divergence equations, is deeply rooted in a misconception about the first-order Maxwell's equations and in an incorrect derivation and use of the curl-curl equations. The divergence equations must be always included in the first-order Maxwell's equations to maintain the ellipticity of the system in the space domain and to guarantee the uniqueness of the solution and/or the accuracy of the numerical solutions. The div-curl method and the least-squares method provide rigorous derivation of the equivalent second-order Maxwell's equations and their boundary conditions. The node-based least-squares finite element method (LSFEM) is recommended for solving the first-order full Maxwell equations directly. Examples of the numerical solutions by LSFEM for time-harmonic problems are given to demonstrate that the LSFEM is free of spurious solutions.