Comparison of the STI NIPIP tracking dynamics identification with the on-line Fourier analyzer DFA results including a time varying case

The Non-Intrusive Pilot Identification Procedure (NIPIP) recently developed at STI and described at the 1981 Annual Manual was used to identify operators who were compensatory tracking a sub-critical-instability task. NIPIP uses a time domain least squares procedure converting to frequency domain coefficients. The forcing function was a sum of sinusoids supplied by the STI Mark II Describing Function Analyzer, which computes on-line Fourier coefficients of the operator's error/input describing function. The resulting open-loop and operator dynamics computed by each procedure are compared, and they are shown to be reasonably close when there is reasonable power in the error signal at the measurement frequencies. A special run was made in which the operator abruptly reduced gain within 1 sec, and the ability of the NIPIP to identify this step time variation in the operator is illustrated.