An Improved Hf Vapor Etching Apparatus for Stardust Particle Extraction

Introduction: The NASA Stardust mission captured thousands of particles from the Jupiter-family comet 81P/Wild 2 in a collector composed of aluminum foil and blocks of silica aerogel [1]. To date, most Wild 2 particles available for study are relatively large and coherent particles extracted individually from the ends of hollow, carrot-shaped impact tracks produced during impact into aerogel. However, >65% of the impacting mass can be found in the ‘bulb’ of the track, including nearly all of the <1 μm size fraction [2]. This fraction contains organic-rich material and is likely to include presolar grains, representing a critical opportunity to constrain the organic and presolar inventory of primitive outer solar system materials. However, the small size and susceptibility of this fraction to melting or alteration during capture poses significant analytical challenges.

Previous attempts to extract and concentrate fine-grained material from the bulb of Stardust tracks have attempted to develop techniques that efficiently destroy aerogel and leave impactor particles relatively unharmed. The low density and high porosity of silica aerogel makes it more susceptible to attack by etching with hydrofluoric acid (HF) [3] or CF4 plasma ashing [4] than collected cometary silicates. Previous studies of HF vapor etching used HF solutions varying between 5 to 49% and noted that at high concentrations and etch rates, a liquid droplet was produced according to the etching reaction 4HF + SiO2 → SiF4 (g) + 2H2O [3]. SiF4 readily decomposes into HF and silicic acid in water, which has the potential to alter the freed cometary silicates. The plasma ashing technique avoids production of a liquid droplet and minimizes damage to embedded silicates but requires specialized equipment [4].

In this abstract, we present recent improvements to the HF etching procedure with the aim of constructing an etching chamber capable of slowly etching silica aerogel using small quantities of dilute HF. The etching chamber can be assembled using readily available materials.